"VIGIK" NFC reader cannot read Flipper's emulation

Hi everyone,
I have been suggested to make a topic here following the post I made on the subreddit.

My building’s hatch uses a VIGIK NFC reader, and the card that opens it is a Mifare Classic 1K. I have successfully read all the 32 keys using my Flipper, yet I do not know if the information is relevant but when I read the NFC card, it took the Flipper a long time (3~4 minutes) to read the 5 first sectors, and then in less than three seconds it rushes the 9 last sectors, and says “Complete!” in the end. Do you think it is a possibility that the Flipper did not read correctly my card even if it says so?

When I emulate it and try to make the reader detect it, it shows a red light telling me that the emulation is seen but it fails to open the hatch.

You can find more info on their website https://www.vigik.com, tho I am not sure there is much to learn…
Do you think this issue is solvable with a software update? In my country (France) most of casual buildings security and stuff uses VIGIK, apparently, which makes the Flipper Zero useless in my place for this purpose.

Thank you for your time, have a great day!

I have found that there might be some interesting information on the Wikipedia page https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vigik

A security researcher has shown many weaknesses on the system. The guy summed up all the info about VIGIK system flaws in this document that I have found in the wiki’s references. The document is fully in english

Mifare Classic emulation is not finished yet, as we haven’t implemented the Nested auth and value commands

Please wait for that to finish, then it’ll probably work


Thanks @Astra for the update, will look forward to this :slight_smile:
@leogarithm indeed I also tested up VIGIK readers and same outcome (tracked on this issue : https://github.com/flipperdevices/flipperzero-firmware/issues/1468)